RotoPass Message Board / Hockey / Trade Advice / What's a good counter offer? / Latest Posts

RE: What's a good counter offer?

vladrules — Thu, 25 Oct 2007 12:08:53 GMT

It's a non keeper league.

[quote]G + Sykora for Cammalleri my get there i suppose but G/Knuble won't imo. they knocked Knuble down off the top line and his value is a little depressed at the moment. unless you can deal him without the other guy knowing that he doesnt have top line duty at the moment. i suppose my comments remain the same in your 2nd trade idea (for Elias).
[/quote]

Good to know. Not sure why Knuble doesn't get more points. Guess, it really is a French connection. He may have to drop him for CClark, GMurray or even MRyder who never saw a shot he didn't like.

[quote]if you don't get Cheechoo you're essentially offering a whack of parts to get Hossa/Emery? i suppose it could fly but i never really like seeing HUGE trade offers (more than a 2fer) coming my way. there's a chance this guy wants to blow his team up though, he aint going anywhere by rostering Aeb, and Ryan. [/quote]

It shouldn't work but it's a casual league so that could happen.

Seems like I'm really keeping these forums busy. :D

Thanks again Ian.

RE: What's a good counter offer?

ian — Thu, 25 Oct 2007 11:20:51 GMT

[quote][b]vladrules (10/25/2007)[/b][hr]Luckily, got Marleau for Dumont. Offered NYR owner Gomez for Cheechoo. Hopefully, can get Cheechoo.

Aebischer sent down and RW Ryan and Clarkson are droppable players.

Possible trade ideas if get Cheechoo for Gomez:
-(Budaj or Bryzgalov) and (Knuble or Sykora) for LW/C Cammalleri?
-Bryzgalov and Knuble for LW/C Elias?

If don't get Cheechoo:
-Gomez, Knuble, PSykora, Budaj, Bryzgalov for Hossa, Emery? He replaces Aebiescher, Ryan, Clarkson.[/quote]

there's a lot of stuff here, would you and your bro be interested in a team review on my blog? email it in if you are.

G + Sykora for Cammalleri my get there i suppose but G/Knuble won't imo. they knocked Knuble down off the top line and his value is a little depressed at the moment. unless you can deal him without the other guy knowing that he doesnt have top line duty at the moment. i suppose my comments remain the same in your 2nd trade idea (for Elias).

if you don't get Cheechoo you're essentially offering a whack of parts to get Hossa/Emery? i suppose it could fly but i never really like seeing HUGE trade offers (more than a 2fer) coming my way. there's a chance this guy wants to blow his team up though, he aint going anywhere by rostering Aeb, and Ryan.

is this a keeper?

RE: What's a good counter offer?

vladrules — Thu, 25 Oct 2007 08:14:12 GMT

Luckily, got Marleau for Dumont. Offered NYR owner Gomez for Cheechoo. Hopefully, can get Cheechoo.

Aebischer sent down and RW Ryan and Clarkson are droppable players.

Possible trade ideas if get Cheechoo for Gomez:
-(Budaj or Bryzgalov) and (Knuble or Sykora) for LW/C Cammalleri?
-Bryzgalov and Knuble for LW/C Elias?

If don't get Cheechoo:
-Gomez, Knuble, PSykora, Budaj, Bryzgalov for Hossa, Emery? He replaces Aebiescher, Ryan, Clarkson.

What's a good counter offer?

vladrules — Wed, 24 Oct 2007 12:15:20 GMT

My bro is 3rd in a 12 team standard 6x4 roto casual public yahoo league w/daily changes.

League:
http://hockey.fantasysports.yahoo.com/hockey/70997

Trigun
C Eric Staal(Car - C)
C Patrick Marleau(SJ - C)
LW Thomas Vanek(Buf - LW)
LW Alex Tanguay(Cgy - LW)
RW Daniel Alfredsson(Ott - RW)
RW Mike Knuble(Phi - RW)
D Dion Phaneuf(Cgy - D)
D Zdeno Chara(Bos - D)
D Kimmo Timonen(Phi - D)
D Francois Beauchemin(Anh - D)
BN Scott Gomez(NYR - C)
BN Petr Sykora(Pit - C,RW)
IR Steve Sullivan(Nsh - RW)

G Miikka Kiprusoff(Cgy - G)
G Ryan Miller(Buf - G)
BN Peter Budaj (Col - G)
BN Ilya Bryzgalov(Anh - G)

Someone offered C/LW Cammallerri, LW RSmyth, LW Stillman, C/LW Elias for C EStaal, D Phaneuf, LW Vanek

Not a very good trade since my bro is trading his 3rd, 4th and 6th picks for 5th, 8th, 10th and 12th pick. What is he supposed to do with so any LW and C? He doesn't think Cammalleri will continue to be the leading goal scorer.

Superstar (6th place)
C Vincent Lecavalier(TB - C)
C Michael Cammalleri (LA - C,LW)
LW Patrik Elias(NJ - C,LW)
LW Ryan Smyth(Col - LW)
RW Marian Hossa(Atl - RW)
RW David Clarkson(NJ - RW)
D Bryan McCabe(Tor - D)
D Kevin Bieksa(Van - D)
D Wade Redden(Ott - D)
D Tom Poti(Was - D)
BN Cory Stillman(Car - LW)
BN Bobby Ryan(Anh - RW) NA
BN Ladislav Nagy(LA - LW)
IR Todd Bertuzzi(Anh - RW) IR

G Evgeni Nabokov(SJ - G)
G Ray Emery(Ott - G)
BN David Aebischer(Pho - G)

Not sure who my bro wants but Emery, Hossa are good targets. Maybe Superstar is interested in RW to replace RW BRyan and Clarkson. Gomez, Sykora, Knuble, Budaj, Bryzgalov are the trade baits.

From earlier post, Ian said Gomez for Cheechoo. So Hossa or Cheechoo?