|
|
|
Rookie
 
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 6/7/2007 8:16:46 PM
Posts: 487,
Visits: 1,423
|
|
| If this trade wasn't offered by the guy leading me by half a game I would probably make this trade, regardless of whether I think it's an even trade- I don't need addai and winslow would be an upgrade at te. But since that's not the case, I was wondering what people thought about the trade all things considered. Here is my roster (way too many players I know and this is a 12 team league): qb- Bulger, rb- LJ, rb- Julius Jones, wr- Holt, wr- Colston, wr- Boldin, te- Witten, k- Kaeding, D- Broncos Bench: rb- T. Jones, rb- Addai, rb- Rhodes, rb- M. Barber, rb- M. Turner, wr- Ike Bruce, wr- B. Johnson, wr- E. Kennision, D- Bills, D- Falcons So I'm pretty deep at rb. I guess Addai might possibly start during the playoffs but it will be hard to start him over one of the Joneses (Colts play Jax first week of my playoffs, so prob not then, but Cincy and Houston final two weeks of playoffs). The other concern is that Dungy rests starters the last couple of weeks and Addai is useless to me. I could offer Jones instead of Addai in return, and he is willing to deal either of his Tes, Winslow and T. Gonzalez. The final consideration is that I would likely be improving the team half a game in front of me without necessarily greatly improving my team (other than Gore, at rb he has Lundy, Mike Bell and a bunch of backups). Thinking this through as I write it I'm pretty convinced I shouldn't do the deal, but I would appreciate any thoughts you guys have. Basically is the improvement of Winslow/Gonzalez over Witten worth giving a solid starting rb to another playoff team? (3 in division make playoffs so we are both a lock at this point). Thanks for reading this rambling nonsense and for any opinion you have.
|
|
|
|
|
Designated Poster
Group: Premium Members
Last Login: 2/28/2008 9:49:20 AM
Posts: 596,
Visits: 366
|
|
| I think the risks outweigh the rewards. If it's me I'm not helping a guy who is deficient at RB who is a possible playoff opponent. I say stick with what ya got and good luck in the playoffs! Smoke "With great power comes great responsibility"
Smoke"With great power comes great responsibility"
|
|
|
|
|
Rookie
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 6/7/2007 8:16:46 PM
Posts: 487,
Visits: 1,423
|
|
|
|
|
|
Rookie
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 9/30/2007 12:30:23 PM
Posts: 121,
Visits: 272
|
|
stew1616 (11/17/2006)
Basically is the improvement of Winslow/Gonzalez over Witten worth giving a solid starting rb to another playoff team?
i say no to this question and agree with Smoke
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
qb-Brady, Losman (play 1)
rb-LT, Deuce, Barber III, F. Taylor (2)
wr-L. Coles, S. Moss, Toomer, Berian, Welker (2)
te-D. Clark,
k-Mason Crosby (1)
d-NE (1)
1pt 10 yds rush/rec
1pt 20 yd passing
6pt all td's
"It is what it is."....B.B.
|
|
|
|
|
Designated Poster
Group: Premium Members
Last Login: 2/28/2008 9:49:20 AM
Posts: 596,
Visits: 366
|
|
| No problem, glad to help. Smoke "With great power comes great responsibility"
Smoke"With great power comes great responsibility"
|
|
|
|
